SecretsPresented by Flexible Productions
The Cock Tavern Theatre, Kilburn
17/11/2009 - 05/12/2009
*The nature of secrecy is explored in an original work that draws inspiration from its actors’ real lives.
We all have secrets that we keep from others: the romantic entanglements that we’d rather not admit to, the illnesses we hide, matters which seem better kept within families, abuse of one form or another, or events from our past of which we are ashamed. The degree to which we choose to reveal these secrets often goes a long way towards defining our relationships and can provide us with closure or with further confusion. However, it is these secrets that follow us through life and which affect us when we least expect them to that help to shape us and to define our actions. This is the concept of “Secrets”, a devised play created in collaboration with eight actors and director Danielle Coleman, and which weaves the real life secrets of its performers into its storyline. The result of weeks of creative work-shopping and improvisational work, “Secrets” promises a uniquely different theatre experience and it delivers, not least of all because its revelations are highly personal. However, where it succeeds in honesty, it fails in overall consistency.
At nearly two hours in length and with eight separate sets of back-story to develop and expound upon, much of the detail in “Secrets” gets lost in the mix. Some scenes are deeply emotional and well fleshed out, particularly those concerning actress Helen Briscoe, while others desperately need further exploration and explanation. Director Danielle Coleman says that this play is about secrets, although not necessarily the revelation of those secrets. As in real life, we never know the full truth behind what is revealed to us, and often we are left to form our own conclusions about what to believe. While this concept does work at times, at other times we are simply provided with too little information about what is happening to form any conclusion at all. This results in confusion, but little else. This may not be a play about revelations, as such, but it still needs some.
Danielle Coleman has undoubtedly provided her actors with a safe and creative environment in which to reveal themselves. Furthermore, this is an enigmatic and talented group, and watching them play off of each other and explore is very entertaining. At the heart of “Secrets” is the idea that all if its characters are connected in some way, and often this connection is through psychologist Andrew Cleaver. Andrew Cleaver is particularly good in his role, with subtle intensity and expressions which betray far more than his dialogue allows. A s a play about character relationships, “Secrets” has some solid, buildable points; the relationship between Helen Briscoe and James Dutton, for example, is appropriately humorous and distressing, and its intensity is fascinating to watch. Additionally, as a teacher who confronts her own past as a schoolyard bully, Ishbel Nicol is believable and sympathetic, particularly in flashback sequences. And Shireen Walton is lovely as a daughter hiding a family secret. Perhaps the biggest disappointment in “Secrets” is that Shireen Walton is not allowed a greater opportunity to build on her character.
Ultimately, “Secrets” has touching moments, some well structured scenes, and a notable cast. However, as a fully formed production, it falls short. There is still a distinct feeling of this being a “workshop”; there are many good moments, but no consistent through line. At the end, there are just too many unanswered questions and too many loose ends. And while the final scene was crucial to the development of Helen Briscoe’s character, it was an odd choice to end the production and only added to the lingering sense of confusion over the point of the play. As it currently is, “Secrets” is recommended for some exceptional acting and the beginnings of an original and entertaining concept. With a little more work and a concise script editor, “Secrets” has the potential to be very good. 3 Stars.
At nearly two hours in length and with eight separate sets of back-story to develop and expound upon, much of the detail in “Secrets” gets lost in the mix. Some scenes are deeply emotional and well fleshed out, particularly those concerning actress Helen Briscoe, while others desperately need further exploration and explanation. Director Danielle Coleman says that this play is about secrets, although not necessarily the revelation of those secrets. As in real life, we never know the full truth behind what is revealed to us, and often we are left to form our own conclusions about what to believe. While this concept does work at times, at other times we are simply provided with too little information about what is happening to form any conclusion at all. This results in confusion, but little else. This may not be a play about revelations, as such, but it still needs some.
Danielle Coleman has undoubtedly provided her actors with a safe and creative environment in which to reveal themselves. Furthermore, this is an enigmatic and talented group, and watching them play off of each other and explore is very entertaining. At the heart of “Secrets” is the idea that all if its characters are connected in some way, and often this connection is through psychologist Andrew Cleaver. Andrew Cleaver is particularly good in his role, with subtle intensity and expressions which betray far more than his dialogue allows. A s a play about character relationships, “Secrets” has some solid, buildable points; the relationship between Helen Briscoe and James Dutton, for example, is appropriately humorous and distressing, and its intensity is fascinating to watch. Additionally, as a teacher who confronts her own past as a schoolyard bully, Ishbel Nicol is believable and sympathetic, particularly in flashback sequences. And Shireen Walton is lovely as a daughter hiding a family secret. Perhaps the biggest disappointment in “Secrets” is that Shireen Walton is not allowed a greater opportunity to build on her character.
Ultimately, “Secrets” has touching moments, some well structured scenes, and a notable cast. However, as a fully formed production, it falls short. There is still a distinct feeling of this being a “workshop”; there are many good moments, but no consistent through line. At the end, there are just too many unanswered questions and too many loose ends. And while the final scene was crucial to the development of Helen Briscoe’s character, it was an odd choice to end the production and only added to the lingering sense of confusion over the point of the play. As it currently is, “Secrets” is recommended for some exceptional acting and the beginnings of an original and entertaining concept. With a little more work and a concise script editor, “Secrets” has the potential to be very good. 3 Stars.
Playing through December 5th at the Cock Tavern Theatre in Kilburn. Review written by Megan Hunter for Fringe Review: http://www.fringereview.co.uk.
